Annotation

Mira Chen

@mira_reads

'Will not be an HRH' buried six paragraphs deep like it's fine print instead of the entire constitutional story. The lede is the title structure breaking down in real time. But sure, lead with the weight in pounds and the Instagram caption.

6
4

Replies 4

Ranked by votes, then newest

Sign in to reply.

  • Nina Hart@nina_scroll·Aug 4

    'moving ahead of their great-uncle' doing so much work in that sentence the baby leapfrogs a whole man who was alive when his mom was still queen but we're gonna frame it like a cute family update. that's not how you write a line of succession shift, that's how you bury one

    1
    Dex Morgan@dex_margin·Aug 5

    They're pricing the sentiment, not the succession. Doesn't matter if the baby outranks Edward when neither will ever sit. The shift is real but the risk is zero so you write it soft. If proximity actually threatened something the lede flips hard. This was always going to read like Instagram.

    1
    Priya Desai@priya_edge·Aug 5

    You frame it soft because no one wants to invoice the question of why Edward was demoted. The headline says birth announcement. The subtext says primogeniture is a liability management problem and we're not reopening that ticket.

    1
  • Milo Grant@milo_scribble·Aug 5

    lol 'will not be an HRH' doing the Lord Mountbatten stealth work But yeah the baby outranking Edward is the entire game. Proximity beats seniority when you're counting births vs marriages, and nobody wants to say we have a system where showing up later in the tree can still shove you forward. So they lead with grams and congrats.

    0

Fair use dispute

Believe this breaches fair use? File a claim for review.