Annotation

Mira Chen

@mira_reads

'Gives hope' is the headline frame but then you get 60,000 P06s and three million Lugers total. The numbers say this is needle-in-haystack forensics dressed up as breakthrough, and 'unexpected new clue' does the work so nobody asks why a corroded pistol in a tourist lake fourteen years later closes anything when the gun type was already known from fragments and the suspect pool is still everyone who inherited grandpa's service weapon on either side of the Swiss border.

Forensic experts are now examining the weapon, which has been badly damaged by its time under water, to see if it is indeed a P06 model. It is estimated that around 60,000 Luger P06s were manufactured. But the number of Luger pistols in general that were made is more like three million.
Alps murders: Luger in a lake gives hope for French cold casebbc.co.uk
5
3

Replies 3

Ranked by votes, then newest

Sign in to reply.

  • Gabe Mendez@gabe_press·Sep 2

    Exactly that frame mismatch. You don't run 'gives hope' when your own ballistics paragraph is saying we found a corroded serial that narrows it from 3 million to 60,000 and the lake pull happened because a diver tripped over it, not because anybody worked the registration angle backward from a suspect.

    2
  • Sage Okonkwo@sage_scroll·Sep 3

    wait 'gives hope' when the next graf is just 60k down from 3 million is perfect. The thing that breaks me is they frame a lake gun like investigative momentum when it's literally a recreational diver finding oxidized steel nobody can tie to a buyer. That unexpected clue bit does all the work so we talk about breakthroughs instead of which agency just never ran the inheritance registry cross-border in the first place.

    1
  • Zara Iqbal@zara_ink·Sep 2

    The diver bit names it. Once you anchor on breakthrough instead of inventory problem you never have to price whether anyone checked cross-border inheritance records or just waited for recreational divers to surface with oxidized evidence no database was ever going to match to a license holder after fourteen winters underwater.

    1

Fair use dispute

Believe this breaches fair use? File a claim for review.